CHLORDANE JMPR 1974
Explanation
Chlordane was evaluated in the Joint Meetings of 1963, 1965, 1967
and 1970 (FAO/WHO, 1964, 1965, 1968 and 1971). Recommended tolerances
for numerous fruits, vegetables, grains and animal products are at
various steps of the Codex Committee on Pesticide Residues (CCPR)
procedure (Alinorm 74/24, Appendix II). The recommended tolerances are
expressed as combined cis- and trans-chlordane for commodities of
plant origin and as combined cis- and trans-chlordane and oxychlordane
for animal products.
The 1974 Meeting of the CCPR has returned items 12.15 to 12.31 to
step 6 and requested the 1974 Joint Meeting to review new data
requested from governments. The purpose of the request was to
determine whether the recommended maximum limits of 0.3 and 0.2 mg/kg
for potatoes (12.15) through collards (12.31) are necessary if only
the alpha (cis)-chlordane and gamma (trans)-chlordane are to be
measured.
RESIDUES IN FOOD AND THEIR EVALUATION
RESIDUES RESULTING FROM SUPERVISED TRIALS
New data from member governments have not been made available to
the 1974 Joint Meeting. Velsicol Chemical Corporation has submitted
new data on the levels and identity of chlordane residues in potatoes,
beets, asparagus, turnips, parsnips, swiss chard, pumpkin, mustard
greens, spinach, and cucumbers. All data were from supervised trials
reflecting registered uses in the USA. US uses are generally
restricted to applications before edible parts form or to soil
treatments.
Eight principal components of chlordane residues have been
identified in the studies and their relative abundance measured after
various periods of weathering. The residues are heptachlor, heptachlor
epoxide, alpha (cis)-chlordane, gamma (trans)-chlordane, nonachlor,
photo-alpha-chlordane, and "compounds C and E" which are two isomers
of chlordane. Not all of the compounds were found in all samples. The
additional metabolite oxychlordane is found only in animal tissues.
Certain other constituents have been postulated but were not detected.
The distribution of residues at any time is complex but the alpha -
and gamma - isomers still appear to be the best index of chlordane
residues at the point of regulation (though not always the most
abundant single component).
The highest residue levels occur in the root crops, and may
occasionally exceed 0.3 mg/kg when total residues are calculated. If
only alpha- and gamma-chlordane are measured, the residues usually do
not exceed 0.2 mg/kg. In the other vegetables studied, the total
residues are usually between 0.1 and 0.2 mg/kg. If only alpha- and
gamma-chlordane are measured, the residues do not exceed 0.1 mg/kg.
The supervised residue trials in the USA would thus tend to support
somewhat lower tolerance levels than the presently recommended
tolerances for combined alpha- and gamma-chlordane residues in the
vegetables 12.15 through 12.31. Lower tolerance levels however would
leave little latitude for the normal variations observed in crops, and
particularly in crops from countries other than the USA for which no
data are available.
METHODS OF RESIDUE ANALYSIS
The principal advance in the technology since 1970 is apparently
the availability of pure reference standards for the individual
constituents. The analytical methods employed in the Velsicol study
were not identified. Presumably they are Velsicol methods AM 0507 and
AM 0508 which were discussed in the JMPR 1970 report referred to
above. These methods, based on electron-capture gas chromatography,
determine the unchanged components of technical chlordane plus their
photolytic and metabolic conversion products. There is no single GLC
column which will provide resolution of all constituents and it is
unlikely that these methods would be suitable for regulatory purposes.
For this reason the Joint Meeting reaffirms the desirability of
regulating chlordane residues through measurement of the alpha- and
gamma-chlordane residues in plants. Satisfactory methods are available
for determination of these two components (FAO/WHO, 1971).
APPRAISAL
The 1974 Meeting of the CCPR has returned the recommended
chlordane tolerances for potatoes (12.15) through collards (12.31) to
step 6 and requested governments to submit new data for the purpose of
showing whether maximum limits of 0.3 and 0.2 mg/kg are required when
the tolerances are expressed as combined alpha (cis)-chlordane and
gamma (trans)-chlordane. Data were made available to the Joint Meeting
by the Velsicol Chemical Corporation on the identity and levels of
chlordane residue components in various root crops and vegetables from
US trails. While the data generally show that the recommended
tolerances are slightly higher than residues reported in the
supervised trials, the Joint Meeting was unable to conclude that there
was sufficient latitude to reduce the recommended tolerances.
The meeting reaffirms the desirability of expressing chlordane
maximum limits for plant products as the combined residues of alpha
(cis)-chlordane and gamma (trans)-chlordane.
FURTHER WORK OR INFORMATION
DESIRABLE
1. Information from Governments on use patterns.
2. Information from countries other than the USA on residues
resulting from approved uses.
REFERENCES
FAO/WHO (1964). Evaluation of the toxicity of pesticide residues in
food. FAO/PL/M/63/13; WHO/Food Add./23.
FAO/WHO (1965). Evaluation of the toxicity of pesticide residues in
food. FAO/PL/1965/10/1; WHO/Food Add./27.65.
FAO/WHO (1968). 1967 Evaluations of some pesticide residues in food.
FAO/PL/1967/M/11/1; WHO/Food Add./68.30.
FAO/WHO (1971). 1970 Evaluations of some pesticide residues in food.
FAO/AGP/1970/M/12/1; WHO/Food Add./71.42.