INTERNATIONAL PROGRAMME ON CHEMICAL SAFETY WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION SUMMARY OF TOXICOLOGICAL DATA OF CERTAIN FOOD ADDITIVES WHO FOOD ADDITIVES SERIES NO. 12 The data contained in this document were examined by the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives* Geneva, 18-27 April 1977 Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations World Health Organization * Twenty-first Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives, Geneva, 1977, WHO Technical Report Series No. 617 ALUMINIUM BIOLOGICAL DATA BIOCHEMICAL ASPECTS (ABSORPTION) Due to formation of insoluble aluminiumphosphate (AlPO4) in the gastrointestinal tract, only a minor amount of orally administered aluminium-salts is absorbed (Jones, 1938; Kirsner, 1943). Groups each of 10 mice received a standard diet containing 170 ppm or 355 ppm aluminium (as aluminum sulfate). There was no significant difference in intake of water, but food intake was significantly less in the group receiving the higher dose. Aluminum balance was studied during the last six days of the test. Intake and faecal excretion of aluminum was significantly higher at the higher dose whereas urinary excretion and retention of aluminum were not. In another study, aluminum balance was measured in eight rats on diet containing 2835 ppm aluminum (as sulfate) for a further eight days. The increased dose rate of aluminum resulted in a reduction of food intake (20 to 15 g/rat/day) and a reduction in average body weight. Aluminum excretion was increased significantly in higher dose group. About 70% of the dose was excreted in the faeces. Retention was increased 20 times (Ondreicka et al., 1966). Two groups of rats were maintained on diets containing 180 ppm or 2835 ppm aluminum (as sulfate for 26 days). Analysis of tissues for aluminum content, showed significantly increased retention in liver, brain, testes, blood and femur of rats in the higher test group (Ondreicka et al., 1966). These balanced studies with mice 25-30% retention was found (Ondreicka et al., 1966) whereas 10% absorption is reported after Al treatment in rats (Kortus, 1967). Men were fed biscuits containing alum phosphate baking powder (ca 8%) in addition to normal dietary items, and blood and urine samples collected two, four, six and eight hours after the meal. Aluminum was frequently found in blood of control men (trace - 0.1 mg/100 ml), and ingestion of the aluminum rich diet caused occasional slight increase of levels of aluminum in the blood. Urine of man, before and after ingestion of the aluminum rich diets only contain small amounts of aluminum (less than 0.5 mgm excreted in 26 hours) (Underhill et al., 1929). Increased concentrations were found in liver, brain, testes, femur and blood (Ondreicka et al., 1966), while also increased bone concentration was observed in uraemic rats (Thurston et al., 1972). Ingested Al is mainly excreted in faeces, but the urinary Al concentration is also increased after Al treatment (Ondreicka et al., 1966). Influence of aluminum on metabolism of phosphorus Groups each of 10 mice were maintained on a diet containing 160 ppm or 355 ppm aluminum (as the chloride) for a period of 40 days, and the phosphorus balance studied during the last six days. At the high dose level, phosphorus retention was significantly lowered, and on some days was negative. The concentration of phosphorus in the liver and femur, was not significantly affected. In another study eight rats were maintained for eight days on a standard diet, and then another eight days on the diet plus 2665 ppm aluminum as sulfate. Addition of aluminum to the diets resulted in decreased food intake with concomitant lower phosphorus intake, and a reduced excretion of phosphorus in the urine. However, the excretion of phosphorus in the faeces was increased (Ondreicka et al., 1966). Rats were dosed with a single oral dose of aluminum chloride (188.2 mg/kg body weight), and then with 32P labelled Na2H32PO4. The distribution of radioactivity was measured in test and control animals. There was significant decrease in incorporation of 32P into blood and all tissues examined. Further studies in which rats were administered aluminum chloride daily (36.5 mg/day) for a period of 52 days, or by a single intragastrtc dose, each treatment being followed by the i.p. injection of 32P labelled sodium phosphate showed that where as the specific activity of the soluble phosphorus fractions isolated from kidney, spleen and liver was not affected by either chronic or acute intoxication, the incorporation of 32P into phospholipids, RNA and DNA fractions was significantly decreased. In another study the influence of chronically administered aluminum chloride (55 days at 36.5 mg aluminum/day) or acutely administered aluminum chloride (single oral dose of 223 mg aluminum/kg as the chloride on day 56 of the study), on the blood serum level of AMP, ADP and ATP of rat, showed that aluminum chloride caused an increase of AMP, ADP and a decrease of ATP (Ondreicka et al., 1966). Biochemical studies (general) Rats treated with aluminium chloride (AlCl3) (200 mg Al/kg bw incorporated in the diet) showed a decrease in glycogen content of liver and muscle after 18 days exposure. Simultaneously lactic acid was increased in these organs, like pyruvic acid in the liver and blood. The co-enzyme A content of the liver was lowered (Kortus, 1967). Al-salts are reported to interfere with the absorption of glucose from the GI-tract (Gisselbrecht, 1957). In vitro studies showed a dose-related inhibition of the conversion of citric acid to alpha-ketoglutarate (Kratchovil et al. 1967), while the decarboxylation of pyruvic acid was increased by Al (Langenbeck, 1957). Al-nitrate did not decrease adenylcyclase and phosphodiesterase activities in rat cerebellum homogenates (Nathanson and Bloom, 1976). The oxygen consumption of liver homogenates from Al treated rats was decreased (Ondreicka et al., 1966). In vitro studies indicate that there is an activation of erythrocyte-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase activity at low (2 mM-aluminium) concentrations whereas at higher concentrations (4 mM-aluminium) erythrocyte gamma-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase activity was depressed. In vivo studies, with rats injected i.p. with 150 mg/kg bw aluminium sulfate, indicated that the hepatic gamma-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase activity was significantly greater than controls (Meredith et al., 1974). TOXICOLOGICAL STUDIES Special studies on the central nervous system Recent studies (Crapper and Tomko, 1975) using sensitive analytical techniques, indicate the cerebral cortical concentrations (between 4 and 6 µg/g dry weight) are associated with alterations in cat nervous tissue. Observations from the same laboratory indicate that the cerebral cortical concentrations in the range of 4-8 µg/g dry weight are also toxic to rabbit brain (Crapper et al., 1976). However, in similar studies conducted with two species of rats they developed neither neurofibrillary degeneration nor progressive encephalopathies following aluminium applications of up to 10 times the aluminium dose effective in cats (King et al., 1975). Special studies on carcinogenicity Long-term administration of 5 ppm Al in drinking water of mice (Charles River CD strain, two groups of 38-47 males and females) increased the number of lymphoma leukaemia tumours in females, but not the number of animals with tumours (Schroeder and Mitchener, 1975a, see long-term studies). A significant increase in tumour incidence was found in male rats (Long Evans Blu: LE strain, two groups with 19-26 males and females) after treatment with 5 ppm Al in drinking water during life time (Schroeder and Mitchener, 1975b). In eight of 18 rats with subcutaneous implants of Al foil local sarcomas were observed (O'Gara and Brown, 1967). No carcinogenic activity was demonstrated in studies using mice, rats, rabbits and guinea-pigs after administration (intraperitoneal, intravenous) of Al powder, Al(OH)3, Al2O3, AlPO4 and Al dextran (Furst, 1969, 1971; Shubik and Hartwell, 1969). Mutagenicity testing No DNA damaging capacity was observed in the recombination assay, using strains of the Bacillus subtilis (Nishioka, 1975). Reproduction Ten mice were treated with an average 19.3 mg Al/kg body weight via drinking water. In the two generations bred, the F1b, F1c, F2a and F2b litters showed growth impairment when compared with 10 controls receiving 160-180 ppm Al in the diet. No influence on the number of litters or offspring is reported. No histopathological abnormalities were observed in liver, spleen and kidneys. Red blood cell counts did not differ in the first and the last generation (Ondreieka et al., 1966). Groups each of 40 mice equally divided by sex were fed diets containing bread leavened with either yeast, or aluminum phosphate or alum. The presence of aluminum leavened bread in the diet resulted in a decreased number of offspring, as well as development of ovarian lesions (Schaeffer et al., 1928). In another study in which groups of mice were fed bread with yeast plus 4% physiological saline mixture, or 13% saline mixture; or bread with alum phosphate baking powder (4.4% Al plus 4% saline mixture) or bread with alum phosphate powder (1.3% Al) for a period of four months. The presence of aluminum treated bread resulted in decreased number of offspring, as well as increased mortality of offspring during first week of life. Ovaries of these animals contained a large number of atritic follicles, and were greatly reduced in size (Schaeffer et al., 1928). Pregnant rats were administered 40-200 mg/kg aluminium chloride intraperitoneally on either gestational days 9, 13, 9-13 or 14-18. Treatment with 100-200 mg AlCl3/kg caused a dose-related increased incidence of maternal deaths; doses of 75-200 mg/kg resulted in extensive liver damage. The incidence of congenital abnormalities (poor ossification and skeletal defects) was higher in treated animals (Bennett et al., 1974). Thirty rats (50-100 g) were used, 20 receiving the synthetic diet, and the other 10 the synthetic diet plus 0.1% soda alum. Growth curves were comparable, and breeding tests produced for three generations, were similar for test and control animals. The progeny of the rats grew normally (Mackenzie, 1932). Acute toxicity LD50 mg/kg References Salt Species Route body weight AlCl3 Mouse Oral 3 800 Ondreicka et al., 1966 AlCl3 Rat Oral 3 700 Spector, 1956 Al2(SO4)3 Mouse Oral 6 200 Ondreicka et al., 1966 Al(NO3)3 Mouse i.p. 320* Hart and Adamson, 1971 Al(NO3)3 Rat i.p. 330* Hart and Adamson, 1971 Al(NO3)3 Rat Oral 4 280 Spector, 1956 * Ten daily injections, 30 days ovservation period. Short-term studies Rat Feeding 6-10 mg Al/day to a group of six rats for four weeks caused an impairment of growth at three and four weeks. Animals supplemented with 0.1% Na2HPO4 showed a normal rate of growth. No histological abnormalities were found in liver, kidney and heart, but rachitic changes were observed in animals not supplemented with phosphorus. In 3/4 out of nephrectomized rats receiving the same amounts of Al(OH)3, an increase of Al in bone was found (Thurston et al., 1972). Groups of five rats which were normal or had 5/6 nephrectomy (total one side, 2/3 other side), were administered drinking water containing 1 or 2% aluminum sulfate. In the case of the nephrectomized animals, all animals receiving 1% Al2(SO4), died within eight days, and those at the 2% level within three days. The clinical syndrome included periorbital bleeding, lethargy and anorexia. None of the normal rats on the test died during this period, but periorbital bleeding occurred in 3/5 rats (Berlyne, 1972). Mice Groups each of 40 mice equally divided by sex were fed diets containing bread leavened with aluminum (2.07 or 4.1 g Al/100 g bread) as aluminum phosphate baking powder for a period of four months. The groups fed bread leavened with aluminum salt developed serious lesions of the digestive tract (Schaeffer et al., 1928). Dog Groups each of eight beagle dogs, equally divided by sex were fed diets containing sodium aluminum phosphate, (acidic) at dietary level of 0.3, 1.0 and 3.0% for 90 days. During this period there were no significant deviations from normally expected body weight gains. There were no significant differences in haematologic parameters, blood chemistry and urine analyses of test groups and controls. At autopsy, organ weights were similar for test and control animals. Histopathological examination of tissues did not reveal any compound- related effects (Industrial BioTest Labs., 1972a). In another study, groups of dogs were fed the same dietary level of sodium aluminum phosphate (basic), and parameters described in previous study were measured. The only compound-related effect observed, was the presence of unusually large renal concretions in 3/8 of the test animals (2M, 1F), fed 3% of the test material (Industrial BioTest Labs., 1972b and c). Long-term studies Mouse No adverse effects on body weight and longevity were observed in mice (54 males and famales per group, Charles River CD strain) receiving 0 or 5 ppm Al (as potassium sulfate) during life time (936 ± 49 days). No details on histopathology are available (Schroeder and Mitchener, 1975a). Rat Two groups of rats (Long Evans, 52 of each sex) received 0 and 5 ppm Al (as potassium sulfate) in drinking water during life time (1064 ± 20 days). No effects were found on body weight, average heart weight, glucose, cholesterol and uric acid level in serum, protein and glucose content and pH of urine. The life span was not affected. The number of male rats with tumours was significantly increased (Schroeder and Mitchener, 1975b). Groups each of 24 rats were maintained on diets containing SAS powder (a mixture of sodium aluminum sulfate and calcium acid phosphate) at dietary levels equivalent to approximately 0, 0.15%, 1.8% or 0.44%.* Some of the test animals were bred for seven successive generations. The SAS had no effect on reproductive performances as measured by number of offsprings, average birth * SAS baking powders contain ca. 20% sodium aluminum sulfate. Thus diet contained 400, 33 and 98 ppm aluminum respectively. weight, average weaning weight and number weaned. Histopathologic examination of kidneys of rats that survived 21 months on the diet did not reveal any significant changes (Lymann and Scott, 1930). OBSERVATIONS IN MAN Estimates of the daily intake vary between 10 and 100 mg/person (Sorenson et al., 1974). The Al concentration in human tissues from different geographic regions was found to be widely scattered, and probably reflected the geochemical environment of the individuals and of locally grown food products (Tipton and Cook, 1965). In healthy human tissues from the United Kingdom the Al concentration was usually below 0.5 µg/g wet weight, but higher levels were observed in liver (2.6 µg/g), lung (18.2 µg/g), lymph nodes (32.5 µg/g) and bone (73.4 µg/g of ash) (Hamilton et al., 1972). In two subjects the intake was found to be 18 and 22 mg/day during a 30-day period. Excretion took place mainly via faeces (respectively 17 and 45 mg/day): 1 mg was found in 24-hour urine. The mean balances were 0 and -24 mg/day (Tipton et al., 1966). The Al concentration in muscle, bone and brain of patients maintained on a phosphorus binding Al gel for at least two years was respectively 14.8, 95.5 and 6.5 µg/g dry weight is 1.2, 2.4 and 2.2 µg/g dry weight in control subjects. Patients on dialysis, who died of a neurologic syndrome of unknown cause (dialysis encephalopathy syndrome) had brain grey matter concentrations of 25 mg Al/kg dry weight, while in controls 2.2 mg/kg was measured (Alfrey et al., 1976). Al levels in some regions of the brain of patients, who suffered from the Alzheimer's disease were in the range of 6-12 µg/g dry weight (control: < 2.7 µg/g dry weight). Involvement of Al in the pathogenesis of the Alzheimer's disease is suggested (Crapper et al., 1973). The aluminium content of brain in Alzheimer's disease, in which the diagnosis was based on histological appearances, revealed an elevated (0.4-107.0 µg/g) aluminiam content (Crapper et al., 1976). The brain of an aluminium ball mill worker with progressive encephalopathy accompanied by dementia and convulsions was found to contain 5 ppm Al (wet weight) which is 20 times the normal concentration (McLaughlin et al., 1962). Oral administration of Al(OH)3 in doses of 15-40 mg Al/kg body weight daily to patients under dialysis is effective in lowering the predialysis Ca-P product. Systematic use of Al(OH)3 over nearly four years in more than 70 patients did not result in the appearance of a particular clinical picture suggesting intoxications and was compatible with a survival rate of more than 85% after three years. The development of metastatic calciferations was prevented, and existing non-vascular and in a few cases vascular metestatic calciferations disappeared (Verberckmoes, 1972). Raised serum Al levels were found in about 1/3 of non-dialysed patients with advanced renal failure receiving 45 g Al resin/day or more or 3-6 g Al(OH)3/day for 7-14 days (Berlyne et al., 1970). Eight patients with chronic renal failure were given 1.5-3.4 g Al (as Al(OH)3)/day for 20-37 days. In all patients there was a decrease in plasma phosphorus. The balance became more negative in four and less positive in one, remained unchanged in two and became positive in one. Patients absorbed 100-568 mg Al daily. Al administration may decrease parathyroid over-activity since in three patients a normalization of serum parathyroid hormone is found when serum Ca is increased and serum phosphorus is lowered (Clarkson et al., 1972). Occurrence and daily intakes Aluminum occurs naturally in foods, the amount found in plants being generally higher than that in animal foods. In the case of plants the level of aluminum present is related to local soil and atmospheric conditions (Truffert, 1950; Campbell et al., 1957). Estimates of the daily intake of aluminium ranges in the published literature from 1.53 to 160 mg/person/day (Sorensen et al., 1974). Tipton (1966) analysed in the diet and excretion of two subjects for 30 days and found that the mean balances were 0.000g and -0.024 g. This reaffirms earlier results (Campbell, 1957) that excessive intake and absorption by a normal individual is followed by prolonged excretion of the excess, following a reduction in intake. REFERENCES Alfrey, A. C., Le Gendre, G. R. and Kaehney, W. D. (1976) The dialysis encephalopathy syndrome, New Engl. J. Med., 294, 184-188 Bennett, R. W., Persaud, T. V. N. and Moore, K. L. (1974) Teratological studies with aluminium in the rat, Teratology, 9 (3), A-14 Berlyne, G. M., Ben-Ari, J., Pest, D., Weinberger, J., Stern, M., Gilmore, G. R. and Livine, R. (1970) Hyperaluminemia from aluminium resins in renal failure, Lancet, 494-496 Berlyne, G. M., Ben-Ari, J., Knopf, E., Yagil, R., Weinberg, G. and Danovitch, G. M. (1972) Lancet, 1, 564 Campbell, J. and Kehoe, R. A. (1957) A.M.A., Arch. Ind. Health, 15, 359 Clarkson, E. M., Luck, V. A., Hynson, W. V., Baily, R. R., Eastwood, J. B., Woodhead, J. S., Clements, V. R., O'Riordan, J. L. H. and De Wardener, H. E. (1972) The effect of aluminium hydroxyde on calcium, phosphorus and aluminium balances, the serum parathyroid hormone concentration and the aluminium content of bone in patients with chronic renal failure, Clin. Sci., 43, 519-531 Crapper, D. R., Krishnan, S.S. and Dalton, A. J. (1973) Brain aluminium distribution in Alzheimer's disease and experimental neurofibrillary degeneration, Science, 180, 511-513 Crapper, D. R. and Tomko, G. J. (1975) Neuronal correlates of an encephalopathy induced by aluminium neurofibrillary degeneration, Brain Research, 97, 253-264 Crapper, D. R., Krishnan, S.S. and Quittkat, S. (1976) Aluminium, neurofibrillary degeneration and Alzheimer's disease, Brain, 99, 67-80 Furst, A. and Haro, R. T. (1969) A survey of metal carcinogenesis, Progr. Exp. Tumor. Res., 12, 102 Furst, A. (1971) Trace elements related to specific chronic disease: cancer, Cancer Geol. Soc. Amer. Men., 123, 109 Gisselbrecht, H., Baufle, G. H. and Duvernoy, H. (1957) Annls. Scient. Univ. Besancon Med., 44, 29, cited by Kortus, 1967 Hamilton, E. I., Minsky, M. J. and Cleary, J. J. (1972) The concentration and distribution of some stable elements in healthy human tissues from the United Kingdom, Sci. Total. Environ., 1, 341-374 Hart, M. M. and Adamson, R. H. (1971) Antitumor activity and toxicity of salts of inorganic group IIIa metals: aluminium, gallium and thallium, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 68, 1623-1626 Industrial BioTest Labs. (1972) IBT No. B747. Unpublished data submitted to Stauffer Chemical Company Industrial BioTest Labs. (1972a) B747. Unpublished data submitted to Stauffer Chemical Company Industrial BioTest Labs. (1972b) B747. Unpublished data submitted to Stauffer Chemical Company Jones, J. H. (1938) Amer. J. Physiol., 124, 230, cited by Ondreicka et al., 1966 King, G. A., De Boni, U. and Crapper, D. R. (1975) Effect of aluminium upon conditioned avoidance response acquisition in the absence of neurofibrillary degeneration, Pharmacol. Blochem. and Behav., 3, 1003-1009 Kortus, J. (1967) The carbohydrate metabolism accompanying intoxication by aluminium in the rat, Experientia., 23, 912-913 Kirsner, J. B. (1943) J. Clin. Invest., 22, 47, cited by Ondreicka et al., 1966 Kratchovil, B., Boyer, S. L. and Hicks, G. P. (1967) Effects of metals on the activation and inhibition of isocitric dehydrogenase, Anal. Chem., 39, 45, cited by Sorenson et al., 1974 Langenbeck, W. and Schellenberger, A. (1957) Über die decarboxylierung der Benztraubensäure durch Aluminium-ionen, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 69, 22, cited by Sorenson et al., 1974 Lyman, J. F. and Scott, E. (1930) Am. J. Hyg., 12, 271 McLaughlin, A. I. G., Kazantzis, G., King, E., Teare, D., Porter, R. J. and Owen, R. (1962) Pulmonary fibrosis and encephalopathy associated with the inhalation of aluminium dust, Brit. J. Ind. Med., 19, 253-263 Meredith, P. A., Moore, M. R. and Goldberg, A. (1974) The effect of aluminium, lead and zinc on gamma-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase, Biochem. Soc. Trans., 2, 1243-1245 Mackenzie, K. (1932) Biochem. J., 26, 833 Nathanson, J. A. and Bloom, F. E. (1976) Heavy metals and adenosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate metabolism: possible relevance to heavy metal toxicity, Mol. Pharmacol., 12, 390-398 Nishioka, H. (1975) Mutagenic activities of metal compounds in bacteria, Mut. Res., 31, 185-189 O'Gara, R. W. and Brown, J. M. (1967) Comparison of the carcinogenic actions of subcutaneous implants of iron and aluminium in rodents, J. Nat. Cancer Inst., 38, 947-953 Ondreicka, R., Grinter, E. and Kortus, J. (1966) Chronic toxicity of aluminium in rats and mice and its effects on phosphorus metabolism, Brit. J. Ind. Med., 23, 305-311 Schaeffer, G., Fontes, G., LeBreton, E., Oberling, C. and Thivolle, L. (1928) J. Hyg., 28, 92 Schroeder, M. A. and Mitchener, M. (1975a) Life-term effects of mercury, methylmercury and nine other trace metals on mice, J. Nutr ., 105, 452-458 Schroeder, M. A. and Mitchener, M. (1975b) Life term studies in rats of aluminium, beryllium and tungsten, J. Nutr., 105, 421-427 Shubik, P. and Hartwell, J. L. (1969) Survey of compounds which have been tested for carcinogenic activity, Suppl. 2, US Public Health Service Publ., No. 149, 3-4 Spector, W. S. (1956) Handbook of toxicology. I. Acute toxicities, Philadelphia, Saunders eds., 16 Sorenson, J. R. J., Campbell, I. R., Tepper, L. B. and Lingg, R. D. (1974) Aluminium in the environment and human health, Environ. Health Persp., 8, 3-95 Thurston, H., Gilmore, G. R. and Swales, J.P. (1972) Aluminium retention and toxicity in chronic renal failure, Lancet., I, 881-883 Tipton, I. H. and Cook, M. J. (1965) Trace elements in human tissue. III. Subjects from Africa, the Near and Far East and Europe, Health Phys., 11, 403 Tipton, I. H., Stewart, P. L. and Martin, P. G. (1966) Trace elements in diets and excreta, Health Phys., 1683-1689 Truffert, L. (1950) Ann. Fals. Fraud., 1 Underhill, F. P., Peterman, F. I. and Sperandeo (1929) Am. J. Physiol., 90, 76 Verberckmoes, R. (1972) Aluminium toxicity in rats, Lancet, I, 750
See Also: Toxicological Abbreviations Aluminium (EHC 194, 1997) Aluminium (WHO Food Additives Series 24) ALUMINIUM (JECFA Evaluation)