FAO Nutrition Meetings Report Series No. 40A,B,C WHO/Food Add./67.29 TOXICOLOGICAL EVALUATION OF SOME ANTIMICROBIALS, ANTIOXIDANTS, EMULSIFIERS, STABILIZERS, FLOUR-TREATMENT AGENTS, ACIDS AND BASES The content of this document is the result of the deliberations of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives which met at Rome, 13-20 December, 19651 Geneva, 11-18 October, 19662 1 Ninth Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives, FAO Nutrition Meetings Report Series, 1966 No. 40; Wld Hlth Org. techn. Rep. Ser., 1966, 339 2 Tenth Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives, FAO Nutrition Meetings Report Series, 1967, in press; Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations World Health Organization 1967 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION NOTES ON THE BIOLOGICAL DATA NOTES TO THE READER ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME ANTI MICROBIALS, ANTIOXIDANTS AND ANTIOXIDANT SYNERGISTS ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME EMULSIFIERS AND STABILIZERS ACCEPTABLE TREATMENT LEVELS FOR SOME FLOUR-TREATMENT AGENTS ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME ACIDS AND BASES ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR SOME OTHER FOOD ADDITIVES THE MONOGRAPHS ANTIMICROBIALS, ANTIOXIDANTS AND ANTIOXIDANT SYNERGISTS Benzoic acid Benzoate, Potassium Benzoate, Sodium Benzoate, Butyl p-Hydroxy Benzoate, Ethyl p-Hydroxy Benzoate, Methyl p-Hydroxy Benzoate, Propyl p-Hydroxy Butylated Hydroxytoluene Diethyl Pyrocarbonate EDTA, Calcium disodium EDTA, Disodium Hydrogen Peroxide Isopropyl Citrate Mixture Monoisopropyl Citrate see Isopropyl Citrate Mixture Propionic acid Propionate, Calcium Propionate, Sodium Sorbic acid Sorbate, Calcium Sorbate, Potassium Sulfur Dioxide Potassium Metabisulfite Sodium Hydrogen Sulfite Sodium Metabisulfite Sodium Sulfite EMULSIFIERS AND STABILIZERS Acetic acid and fatty acid esters of glycerol Cellulose, Hydroxypropyl Methyl Cellulose, Methyl Ethyl Cellulose, Sodium Carboxymethyl Cholic acid (and Na salt) Cholic acid, Desoxy- (and Na salt) Citric acid and fatty acid esters of glycerol Diacetyltartaric acid and fatty acid esters of glycerol Diglyceride, acetylated, citrated, lactated or tartrated see Acetic acid, Citric acid, etc. Lactic acid and fatty acid esters of glycerol Mixed tartaric acid and acetic acid and fatty acid esters of glycerol Polyglycerol esters of fatty acids Propylene glycol esters of fatty acids FLOUR TREATMENT AGENTS Azodicarbonamide Chlorine Iodate, Calcium Iodate, Potassium Nitrogen Oxides Peroxides, Acetone Peroxide, Calsium Persulfate, Ammonium Persulfate, Potassium Stearyl Tartrate ACIDS Acetic acid Adipic acid Monocalcium phosphates Citric acid Fumaric acid Gluconic acid see Glucono-delta-lactone Glucono-delta-lactone (Glucosic acid) Hydrochloric acid DL-Lactic acid DL-Malic acid BASES Carbonate, Ammonium Carbonate, Calcium Carbonate, Magnesium Carbonate, Potassium Carbonate, Sodium Carbonate, Ammonium Hydrogen Carbonate, Potassium Hydrogen Carbonate, Sodium Hydrogen Hydroxide, Ammonium Hydroxide, Calcium Hydroxide, Magnesium Hydroxide, Potassium Hydroxide, Sodium Oxide, Calcium Oxide, Magnesium OTHERS Mannitol Polyvinylpyrrolidone Sorbitol INTRODUCTION The monographs contained in this report are the result of the deliberations of the ninth1 and tenth2 sessions of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives. Therefore the monographs should be consulted together with these reports. The opinions recorded are based upon scientific evidence made available to the members at the time of the meeting. Every effort was made to obtain all the information on each substance but it is almost inevitable that some work has been missed. The committee offered its apologies to these whose work may not have been taken into consideration. Specifications on these food additives will be forwarded as working papers to the participants at the Fourth Session of the Codex Committee on Food Additives September 1967, and to interested organizations, and will also be available on request from the Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards Branch (Codex Alimentarius), FAO, Rome. 1 FAO Nutrition Meetings Report Series, 1966, No. 40; Wld Hlth Org. techn. Rep. Ser., 1966, 339 2 FAO Nutrition Meetings Report Series, in press; Wld Hlth Org. techn. Rep. Ser., in press NOTES ON THE BIOLOGICAL DATA The Committee agreed that the monographs dealing with the evaluation of the biological data should be drafted along the lines adopted in the previous reports. The Committee at its tenth session also agreed to support in principle the recommendations made by the Scientific Group on Procedures for Investigating Intentional and Unintentional Food Additives.1 Acceptable Daily Intake The Committee decided to retain the method of expressing the acceptable daily intake that had been adopted in earlier reports and, in appropriate cases, to continue to divide the over-all zone of acceptability into two parts. For detailed discussion see the Seventh Report.2 The first part of the over-all acceptable daily intake zone has been termed the unconditional zone of acceptability, and this represents levels of use that are effective technologically, at least for some purposes, and can be safely employed without further expert advice. The second part consists of a conditional zone of acceptability and represents levels of use that can be employed safely but at which it is thought desirable that some degree of expert supervision and advice should be readily available. Acceptable Treatment Level In regard to the flour-treatment agents, the main toxicological and nutritional considerations are concerned with treated flour rather than with the food additive itself. The Committee followed the procedure adopted in the Seventh Report2 for benzoyl peroxide, chlorine dioxide and potassium bromate and recommended levels of flour treatment for this group of additives instead of setting an acceptable level of daily intake. Grouping of related food additives As a number of food additives are closely related chemically and toxicologically, the Committee adopted a system of grouping of food additives. The acceptable daily intake is expected to cover all the specified members of the group that may be included in the diet. In some cases, a given food additive may be related to two groups, in which case the level in the diet must not exceed the maximum acceptable level for either group. The problem is not as complicated as it may appear at first sight, since many of the substances in a group of additives are likely to be used as alternatives to each other. 1 Wld Hlth Org. techn. Rep. Ser., 1967, 348 2 FAO Nutrition Meetings, Report Series, 1964, 35; Wld Hlth Org. tech. Rep. Ser., 1964, 281 Request for further work Previous monographs have often listed further work that seemed to be desirable. However, it is only in relatively few cases that the studies requested have been done, although in some cases the work may be urgently needed in the interests of the consumer. The Committee at its ninth session, therefore agreed to request, in the monographs, only work that is urgently needed in the interests of safety. All other suggestions for further work that may seem desirable, but not so urgently needed, are included under the heading "Comments". The Committee draws the attention of manufacturers and users of food additives to the fact in future, if a statement about farther work being required is included in a monograph, this matter should be given urgent attention. If the additive in question is one that is already in use, its continued use will be supported by the Committee only if the further work required has been carried out and the results justify continuance of the use of the additive. If no action is taken to provide the further evidence that is required, it will be assumed that neither the manufacturers nor the users are interested in continuing the use of the additive. In this case, the Committee may well decide to recommend the prohibition of its use. If the food additive is a new substance not yet in use and if further work has been required, a conditional intake level may be established for a limited period to allow the results of this additional work to be submitted and studied. References Authors who have submitted papers relevant to a given monograph but who are not mentioned in it may rest assured that their work has been consulted. In the interest of brevity, however, the bibliographies of some monographs may be restricted to more recent or more extensive investigations in the field in question. The pioneering achievements of the earlier workers in these fields are fully appreciated. NOTES TO THE READER Further general remarks on the biological data and toxicological evaluation in these monographs as well as reference to the other food additives considered by the Joint Expert Committee may be found in a publication entitled "Explanatory Notes on the Activities of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives".1 Any new information and comments relating: to biological data and their evaluation should be addressed to: Food Additives Unit, World Health Organization, Avenue Appia, Geneva, Switzerland. 1 Off-print from Tenth Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME ANTIMICROBIALS, ANTIOXIDANTS AND ANTIOXIDANT SYNERGISTS Over-all daily intake zone1 (mg/kg body-weight) Compounds considered Unconditional Conditional Benzoic Acid Benzoate, Potassium Benzoate, Sodium 0-52 5-102 Benzoate, Butyl p-Hydroxy Decision postponed Benzoate, Ethyl p-Hydroxy Benzoate, Methyl p-Hydroxy 0-23 2-73 Benzoate, Propyl p-Hydroxy Butylated Hydroxyanisole 0-0.54 0.5-24 Butylated Hydroxytoluene EDTA, Disodium 0-1.255 1.25-2.55 EDTA, Calcium disodium Hexamethylenetetramine Decision postponed Hydrogen Peroxide Restricted uses Isopropyl Citrate Mixture 0-7 7-20 1 The first part of the over-all acceptable intake zone is termed unconditional and this represents levels which can be safely used without further expert supervision and advice. The second part is termed conditional and represents levels of use that can be safely employed but at which it is thought desirable that some degree of expert supervision and advice should be readily available. 2 As sum of benzoic acid and sodium and potassium benzoate (calculated as benzoic acid). 3 As sum of methyl, ethyl, and propyl esters of p-hydroxybenzoic acid. 4 As sum of butylated hydroxytoluene and butylated hydroxyanisole. 5 As calcium disodium EDTA. The use of disodium EDTA is recommended only for accurately chelating calcium. ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME ANTIMICROBIALS, ANTIOXIDANTS AND ANTIOXIDANT SYNERGISTS (continued) Over-all daily intake zone (mg/kg body-weight) Compounds considered Unconditional conditional Propionic Acid Propionate, Calcium Propionate, Sodium 0-101 10-201 Sorbic Acid Sorbate, Calcium 0-12.52 12.5-252 Sorbate, Potassium Sulfur dioxide Potassium metabisulfite Sodium sulfite 0-0.353 0.35-1.53 Sodium metabisulfite Sodium hydrogen sulfite Antimicrobial for certain Acceptable level of beverages treatment (ppm) Diethyl Pyrocarbonate 0-300 1 As sum of propionic acid and calcium and sodium propionate (calculated as propionic acid). 2 As sum of sorbic acid and calcium and potassium sorbate (calculated as sorbic acid). 3 As sum of sulfur dioxide, sodium sulfite, sodium and potassium metabisulfite and sodium hydrogen sulfite (calculated as SO2). ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME EMULSIFIERS AND STABILIZERS Over-all daily intake zone1 (mg/kg body-weight) Compounds considered Unconditional Conditional Cellulose, Sodium Carbozymethyl- Higher levels Cellulose, Hydroxypropyl Methyl- 0-302 for dietetic Cellulose, methyl- or calorie Cellulose, Methylethyl- control purposes Acetic acid and fatly acid esters of glycerol Citric acid and fatty acid esters of glycerol Lactic acid and fatty acid 0-1003 esters of glycerol4 Mixed tartaric and acetic and fatty acid esters of glycerol5 Diacetyltartaric acid and fatty acids esters of glycerol5 0-25 25-50 Polyglycerol esters of fatty 0-12.5 12.5-25 acids Propylene glycol esters of fatty 0-206 20-606 acid. Cholic and Desoxycholic acids 0-1.25 and their salts 1 The first part of the over-all acceptable daily intake zone is termed unconditional and this represents levels which can be safely used without further expert supervision and advice. The second part is termed conditional and represents levels of use that can be safely employed but at which it is thought desirable that some degree of expert supervision and advice should be readily available. 2 As sum of these cellulose derivatives 3 As sum of these fatty emulsifiers. 4 The conditional zone of acceptability for the total intake of D(-)-lactic acid is 0-100 mg/kg. 5 The zone of acceptability for the total food additives intake of tartaric acid is 0-6 mg/kg (unconditional) and 6-20 mg/kg (conditional). 6 As propylene glycol. ACCEPTABLE TREATMENT LEVELS FOR SOME FLOUR-TREATMENT AGENTS Name Acceptable levels of treatment(ppm) Azodicarbonamide 0-45 Chlorine No level set Iodate, Calcium Use not recommended Iodate, Potassium Use not recommended Nitrogen Oxides No level set Peroxides, Acetone No level set Peroxide, Calcium No level set Persulfate, Ammonium No level set Persulfate, Potassium No level set Stearyl Tartrate 0-5001 1 See monograph on Stearyl tartrate ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME ACIDS AND BASES Over-all daily intake zone1 (mg/kg body-weight) Compounds considered Unconditional Conditional Acids Acetic acid Not limited Adipic Acid 0-5 Citric Acid Not limited Fumaric Acid 0-6 6-10 Glucono-delta-lactone 0-15 15-50 (gluconic acid) Hydrochloric Acid Not limited DL-Lactic Acid 0-1002 DL-Malic Acid 0-1003 Monocalcium Phosphates Not limited4 Bases Carbonate, Ammonium ) Carbonate, Calcium ) Carbonate, Magnesium ) Not limited5 Carbonate Potassium ) Carbonate, Sodium ) Carbonate, Ammonium Hydrogen ) Carbonate, Potassium Hydrogen ) Not limited5 Carbonate Sodium Hydrogen ) Hydroxide, Ammonium ) Hydroxide Calcium ) Hydroxide, Magnesium ) Not limited5 Hydroxide Potassium ) Hydroxide, Sodium ) Oxide Calcium ) Not limited5 Oxide, Magnesium ) 1 The first part of the over-all acceptable daily intake zone is termed unconditional and this represents levels which can be safely used without further expert supervision and advice. The second part is termed conditional and represents levels of use that can be safely employed but at which it is thought desirable that some degree of expert supervision and advice should be readily available. 2 Refers to content of D(-)-lactic acid. 3 Refers to content of D(-)-malic acid. 4 Subject to limits of phosphorus load given in the Seventh Report (Wld Hlth Org. techn. Rep, Ser., 1964, 281, 31). 5 Provided that use is in accordance with good manufacturing practice. ACCEPTABLE DAILY INTAKES FOR MAN OF SOME OTHER FOOD ADDITIVES Over-all daily intake zone1 (mg/kg body-weight) Compounds considered Unconditional Conditional D-Mannitol 0-50 50-150 Sorbitol Not limited Polyvinylpyrrolidone 0-1 1 The first part of the over-all acceptable daily intake zone is termed unconditional and this represents levels which can be safely used without further expert supervision and advice. The second part is termed conditional and represents levels of use that can be safely employed but at which it is thought desirable that some degree of expert supervision and advice should be readily available.
See Also: Toxicological Abbreviations